Every Version of You by Natalie Messier
When she reluctantly arrives at the very couple-y dinner party hosted by the best friend she’s secretly pined after for fifteen years, she’s dismayed to find that the last person on earth she’d ever want to see again is also there. Alex Aquino is your basic rich Silicon Beach bro asshole... and the married man Joey once had an affair with.
The night couldn’t possibly get worse– and then she dies. When Joey is given a second chance at life, she finds herself eighteen again, the year she first met both Ellie and Alex.
Armed with memories from her first life, Joey is certain she's come back to finally convince Ellie to see her as more than just a friend, but he doesn’t text or call and is weirded out when she transfers into his class. Then there’s Alex, who’s different than Joey remembers. Charming. Sweet. Considerate. He pursues her, and she can’t deny the chemistry between them . . . but is knowing who a person becomes in the future a reason to stop loving them in the present?
Review: Josephina "Joey" Vasquez is a 33-year-old lawyer that lives with a lot of regrets. Yes, she is successful, but she doesn't enjoy her career. And she is doomed to watch her best friend Ellie (Elijah) be married to another woman. Then, on the way home, Joey dies. But she's given a second chance at life - a do-over. She finds herself 18 years old again, with a chance to life a life without the oppressing weight of the regrets that she had the first go around.
I have to tell you that I have a weakness for this brand of magical realism novels along the lines of the 13 Going on 30 film. My absolute favorites are The Good Part by Sophie Cousens and What Alice Forgot by Liane Moriarty. I don't think this one topped either of those for me, but I still liked a lot of it.
Favorite parts:
- The magical realism do-over plot. SO fun. Don't we all fantasize about the chance to re-do some parts of our life, whether big or small?
- Love that this sends Joey back to college but yet she has the hindsight of her adult perspective. It felt very nostalgic to see her going to parties and navigating classes and the social scenes.
- I liked this novel's idea that there is no one "right" way to live your life. Each iteration is imperfect. It is not only Joey that is making different choices. And she's still imperfect! No one is going to get life completely right: "I'm still me - with the same faults and blind spots. Still prone to the same mistakes. Even if I try to live completely differently, I might still fall into the same traps but with different names."
- Loved her cat Ruthie and the way she was tied into both timelines!
- Despite being frustrated by some of the plot choices, I did really like how this book tied everything together and ended. I felt satisfied with the conclusion and bumped up my rating half a star because it was so well done.
- Loved the minority rep in this. Joey and Alex are both Mexican American and Joey's roommate is Black.
- Joey was very unpredictable. Despite being a 33-year-old who's defining regret is not getting with her longtime best friend when she has the chance, she almost immediately moves her attention and energy on to another person? She claims she was in love with Ellie for years and then just drops it that quickly??
- And despite being an adult in an 18-year old's body, I thought she made a lot of immature choices and reminded me more of a teenager's actions than an adult.
- There's some conversation around her being mentally 33 but sleeping with an 18-year-old and I have to be honest - it gave me the ick. Especially later when we learn what the 18-year-old was thinking during and after the exchange. I was very uncomfortable and not fully sure consent was present.
- I did not like the storyline where she meets up with other do-over individuals. I just thought it felt unnecessary and I find that when the magical realism bit is discussed in too much detail, I start to find it less believable.
- Obviously not every character has to be a reader, but man did the author drill down hard on how much Joey hated reading. It just seemed like an odd choice, knowing everyone reading it likely a reader and feels otherwise.

Comments
Post a Comment